Posted by: Cat | May 8, 2008

Stars vs. Red Wings – a Preview

So I’m doing something a little different here.  I’ve talked to a Red Wings fan (GASPSHOCKHORROR) and we’ve both written up little ditties about why our teams will win.  Only one of us can end up correct on that.  Only time will tell!  So, I present to you,

Why the Stars will win:

Despite how frightened most people I know are of this series (and me, too, I’ll admit it freely), I really think the Stars have a shot.  You can look at the regular season record against the Wings all you want, but this is a different beast.  You want reasons?  Oh, I’ll GIVE you reasons.

The acquisition of Brad Richards at the trade deadline didn’t look so awesome in the month of March.  And then, suddenly, the playoffs hit and BOOM!  Dallas had three capable scoring lines, centered by Mike Ribeiro, Mike Modano, and Brad Richards.  Not to say that the Stars had no depth in scoring beforehand, but having a guy like Brad Richards, who exhibits some patience with the puck and makes smart passes, certainly helps.  Winger Brenden Morrow has been nothing short of a William Wallace-esque leader in the two series that have passed, always able to give a little bit more to get his team into it.  No one will soon forget that quadruple-overtime game and the goal Brenden scored to win it.  Some lesser known names have stepped up as well – Stu Barnes has suffered concussion-like symptoms since that big hit in a game against San Jose, but Toby Petersen, the fourth-line center, stepped up and picked up his minutes in that magical game six.  Antti Miettinen was the one to score the Stars’ first goal in game six, Loui Eriksson has six points in the playoffs, and Joel Lundqvist has four.  If these guys can keep playing at this level, I have no doubt that they can push through Detroit’s defense, good as it is.

The Dallas defense has been pretty awesome since Sergei Zubov got back to 100% (although he’ll argue that he’s only at 99% – possibly still upset with himself about those two intercepted passes?).  I will fully admit that Detroit’s defense is absolutely incredible, and Dallas’s might not match up.  Sure, we have Zubov back, but we do still have three rookies back there (Nicklas Grossman, Mark Fistric, and Matt Niskanen).  There are, though, two guys who have been incredible.  Stèphane Robidas took a puck to the face and came back to the game after suffering a broken nose (insert your own joke there about poor Robi and his poor nose).  Mattias Norstrom surprised the hell out of me with his five points (two goals, three assists) and fairly awesome play.  Philippe Boucher suffered an unfortunate injury in the Anaheim series, but he is apparently skating again, which has to mean he’s close.  Right?  RIGHT?!?  One could say that the Dallas blueline will be outmatched, like, hardcore.  Then again, you could have said that about the Ducks as well, who have an experienced and talented blueline.  The Stars seemed to handle that okay.

And, of course, goaltending.  You know what?  I don’t even want to talk about it too much.  Everyone is making a big deal out of Marty Turco’s record at the Joe, but this has been the season of shaking monkeys off backs.  I’m fairly certain Marty can shake this monkey off, too.  Sure, he has a 2-10-5 lifetime record against the Wings.  Sure, he’s never won in Detroit.  But you know what?  Right now he’s boasting a 1.73 GAA and a .929 save percentage.  Those aren’t numbers I’d want to mess with, even if I am Chris Osgood with a 1.52 GAA and .937 save percentage.  Marty seems to have a fire in him right now, a certain determination, and that will fuel him through this series.

The Stars have asked me to believe, and I have.  I will continue to, despite how scared and nervous I might get.  The Stars have faith in themselves.  People are comparing this 07-08 team to the ’99 team that won the Stanley Cup.  This team will have to fight hard, undoubtedly.  Will they?  I have no doubt in my mind.  Will their fans believe in them?  I think so – I certainly will.  Every member of the Stars organization believes that this team has what it takes, and I do too.

Behind the jump, find out why Steph believes that the Red Wings will win. 

Why the Wings will win:

First and foremost, depth.  That’s not to say that Dallas is over there running a one line team, but the Detroit is literally overstocked with playoff-capable guys.  The Datsyuk-Zetterberg-Holmstrom line is always formidable (and looks to be sticking together for now), but the second line of Filppula-Franzen-Samuelsson is just as scary.  The Hudler-McCarty-Helm line looked spectacular against the Avalanche.  Every line is trouble.  The hard hitting combo of the finally healthy Niklas Kronwall and trade deadline acquisition (thanks again Connie!) Brad Stuart is just worrisome to opponents as the skilled playmakers Nick Lidstrom and Brian Rafalski.  And Dominik Hasek, despite losing his job to Chris Osgood and playing pretty damn shaky in those two series two games, isn’t yet something suited only to laugh at either.  And the truly scary thing is the guys waiting in the wings – maybe they aren’t the most talented guys, but the Wings don’t have a single liability.  Lose a forward (potentially Filppula) and Kirk Maltby with all his playoff experience is ready to join his former grind line partners.  A defenseman, and Andreas Lilja is ready – and sure, sometimes he’s sketchy, but the fact is for the better part of the season he was out there every night, and while he it’s obvious the organization (rightfully) doesn’t trust the final top four d-man spot to him, look at the season we had with him there.  This leads to the biggest asset the Wings have going into this series – the puck possession game they can play constantly with this much talent means the pressure never lets up.  There’s never a chance for the opposition to breathe; the Wings just keep coming – and they’re not afraid, anymore, to play a down and dirty style hockey game – which is exactly what we expected last series, and exactly what we might get this series.

And in tandem with that depth and pressure, sheer goalscoring.  In the first series, Johan Franzen along put up as many goals as the Colorado Avalanche as a team.  Throughout the first two rounds of the playoffs, Detroit scored 38 goals total.  Of course, Dallas scored 35, a very comparable number, but can the Dallas defense neutralize powerhouses like Franzen (11 playoff goals so far), Zetterberg (7) and Datsyuk (5) easier than Detroit can Dallas top producers Brenden Morrow (7), Mike Modano (4), and Jere Lehtinen (4)?  Doubtful.

And then there’s goaltending.  Detroit’s stellar defense plays a huge role in the success of its goaltenders no doubt, but Chris Osgood, while he might not be the sort of goalie to steal games for us, is certainly the sort who won’t lose them for us, either.  Since he replaced Hasek in game in game 5 of round 1, he hasn’t lost yet.  And while it might be jinxing it to mention it – and (you knew it was coming) while it certainly isn’t anything you want to play real faith in – it’s hard to ignore that Dallas’ Marty Turco, while playing out of his mind at some points not only this year but in last years’ playoffs as well, has a 2-10-5 lifetime record against the Red Wings, which includes an 0-7-2 record in Detroit, where he has posted a 3.38 goals-against average and a .882 save percentage.  Ouch, Marty.

Finally, the Wings believe.  Countless members of the team, the organization, the fanbase, have mentioned that this is the best Wings team they’ve seen since the last cup.  Will it be easy?  Of course not.  Maybe they won’t be able to dominate the way they did in round two, maybe they’ll have to dig deeper through their wealth of skill, talent, grit, determination, confidence, than they have up to this point.  But can they do it?  You bet.  They’re simply too well put together at team not to – and I think they know that too.  They’re smart.  They’re scary.  They’re healthy.  And it would take a hell of a lot to get past them feeling the way they do right now.



  1. This series is giving me fits already. I don’t know what to do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: